Search

Why Are Israel (And Brooklyn) Doing So Badly With The Pandemic?


Haredi mask burning in Brooklyn

On Sunday, Israel reported 3,756 new cases of COVID, a very high number for such a small country. Monday there were 7,189 more and today another 7,191. That's 76,511 cases per million residents. That's almost as bad as the U.S. (83,658 cases per million) and much worse than the western European countries Israel likes being compared to: Holland (58,848/million), U.K. (58,325/million), France (51,410/million), Italy (43,957/million) and Germany (27,422/million). With a population of just over 9 million-- the 96th most in then world-- Israel has the 19th most critical cases right now. How is that possible? We've tried to explain the ultra-Ordoxdox, or Haredi Jews, a few times but it's very uncomfortable because I keep using horribly bigoted words like primitive, backward and idiotic that I then feel ashamed of.

Unfortunately, though, this is the community that has been spreading COVID, not just in Israel but in Brooklyn as well. And people are getting pissed off-- big time. Steve Hendrix is the Washington Post's bureau chief in Israel and Shira Rubin is one of their journalists based there. Last night they reported from Bnei Brak, a Haredi self-imposed ghetto where COVID is rampant and where violence from right-wing Haredim might make you think you're in Wyoming.

Normal Israelis have had enough of these people-- and there is nothing they can do about it. Meet the Shinfelds, "an ultra-Orthodox Jewish family in this most religious of cities, are used to being a bit at odds with the rest of Israel. Their community's tradition of large families-- the couple has 10 children and 30 grandchildren-- strict observance and exemption from military service have long created friction with the more secular majority. But they say they have never felt hostility like they do now, as a pandemic-exhausted nation has turned its rage at ultra-Orthodox scofflaws. As Israel endures its third national lockdown, social media has been inflamed by images of black-clad men brazenly crowding schools, weddings and other events, including 20,000 at a recent Jerusalem funeral of a leading rabbi. Secular critics have cast the ultra-Orthodox, fairly or not, as superspreaders supreme, a drag chute on the country’s race to vaccinate its way out of the coronavirus’s grip. 'Now it’s not only tense-- it feels like hatred,' said Vivian Shinfeld, 60, of the anger she feels even from some less-religious members of her own family. 'Now it is starting to feel like a war.'"

Worse yet, the Shinfelds "consider themselves 'modern' ultra-Orthodox," not the ones still living in medieval eastern Europe. "They wear masks, have been vaccinated and condemned the covid-19 violators who torched a bus a few blocks from their house in protest of lockdown restrictions. But they too have become pariahs, ghosted by old friends and unable to get a repairman to come fix their refrigerator. The backlash could have cultural and political impacts well after the pandemic ends."


“There has been a schism growing for a while, and the pandemic is making it wider,” said Tamar El-Or, an anthropology professor at Hebrew University and longtime scholar of ultra-Orthodox culture. “When this virus is gone, nothing is going to be same.”
The ultra-Orthodox-- or Haredim as they are known in Hebrew-- largely shun modern society. For decades, Israeli governments have accorded them autonomy in exchange for their leaders’ support in parliament and subsidized a lifestyle that favors Torah study over employment with welfare payments.

It's worth mentioning that New York's state and city governments have treated the Orthodox and Hassidic communities with the same wretchedly corrupt kid-gloves, helping to engender the same massive sense of entitlement and social-selfishness. How many New Yorkers, let along Israelis feel the same way as Yair Lapid, a leader of the opposition in the Knesset, who said that "It’s time that we have one law, for everyone." At least Israel doesn't even pretend to have separation of church and state-- unlike, say, New York.

National elections are scheduled for March 23, and opponents have seized on the anger as a cudgel against Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu, who is blamed for not enforcing restrictions in a sector essential to his ruling coalition. (Just 2 percent of the fines issued last year for violating coronavirus restrictions were in ultra-Orthodox areas, according to Be Free Israel, a group advocating for religious pluralism.) Haredi parties, which often serve as kingmakers in the parliament, hold 16 seats. Polls, including one released in earlier this month by Channel 12 News, indicate 60 percent or more of all Israelis want ultra-Orthodox parties out of government.
In January, Defense Minister Benny Gantz proposed ending the ultra-Orthodox exemption from conscription, which is mandatory for other Israeli Jews. Academics and business leaders are renewing their calls for Haredi schools to teach basic math and science. Meantime, some secular lawmakers continue to target the per-child welfare payments that support large Haredi families.
Even within the community, tensions are emerging between hard-liners and others who have begun to seek education and careers outside their neighborhoods.
“You can’t ignore it anymore,” said Hila Lefkowitz, an ultra-Orthodox activist who is running for parliament as part of a new alternative religious party. “The way that the Haredi society functions, with its independence, now we are seeing the problems with that.”
The contentious relationship between public health officials and the Haredim goes back to the beginning of the pandemic. Most rabbinical leaders did obey early orders to close schools and synagogues, but only reluctantly, citing the central role of daily religious gatherings in Haredi life.
As pandemic fatigue set in, defiance grew. Some rabbis, complaining that secular Israelis were being allowed to gather at mass political protests against Netanyahu each week, ordered the religious schools, called yeshivas, to reopen. Weddings and funerals continued, some of them drawing hundreds. Making up 12 percent of the population, the ultra-Orthodox have accounted for more than a quarter of positive coronavirus cases, according to Health Ministry data.
Two months into the vaccine campaign, Israel’s rate of new infections has only just begun to bend downward. Its seven-day average of 6,952 of new positive cases is down over three weeks from 8,624.
Government dictates, in any case, are anathema to the ultra-Orthodox, many of whom reject state power in favor of biblical authority. As in the United States, covid restrictions became political.
“If the government says, ‘Wear a mask,’ that’s a reason for them not to wear a mask,” said Itzhak Shinfeld.
Modern Haredim-- who adhere to halacha , or Jewish law [think Sharia], but don’t outright reject mainstream life-- fear that tensions between their community and wider Israeli society could rupture the growing ties between these two worlds.
Almost two-thirds of ultra-Orthodox are under 19 and are entering the workforce in greater numbers. According to Israel’s Central Bureau of Statistics, more than 76 percent of Haredi women work outside the home now, even as men still mostly chose a life of Torah scholarship. The number of ultra-Orthodox students in higher education has more than doubled in the past decade, although it remains below 13 percent.
Itzhak Shinfeld, who has recently been able to hire Haredi plumbers and electricians, worries that this modest progress will be reversed if secular politicians clamp down on the ultra-Orthodox in the name of controlling the pandemic.
“We are in the middle of a big integration,” he said. “The minute they feel oppressed, they will close up the box again.”
Shinfeld, 61, illustrates the divide within the Haredi world. He was born and raised in Bnei Brak, one of the country’s centers of ultra-Orthodox life, and educated at Israel’s largest yeshiva. He still wears the traditional broad black hat and knee pants of the Gur sect each Sabbath and has no television in his house.
But, after studying the Torah for an hour every morning, he works as a lawyer and owns a construction company. During a recent weekday visit on his patio, he wore a blue dress shirt and black yarmulke. He served in the Army in the 1980s, reaching the rank of captain, something unthinkable for stricter Haredim. Lockdown tensions have only widened the gap between security forces and the ultra-Orthodox, some of whom have taken to pelting police patrols with rocks.
“Things that were normal then are not normal now,” he said, fingering his smartphone.
Some relatively moderate members of the community say they believe their rabbis have failed them by openly defying government closure orders, and this, in some instances, has called into question the male-dominated hierarchy. Some Haredi women feel emboldened now in asking for a greater say.
“There's no more trust between the community and its leaders,” said Lefkowitz. “So there are people who would never have entered political life now entering.”
The Shinfelds hold their more conservative leaders accountable leaders for flouting covid restrictions. But police, too, bear responsibility for the worst clashes, they say, by storming into their streets in a way that wouldn’t happen in a secular Tel Aviv neighborhood. Online scolds have dubbed their community a “death cult,” but the couple share the belief widely held among the ultra-Orthodox that they have been singled out.
“I don’t want to see the synagogues open, but they should also close the protests,” Itzhak Shinfeld said.

Do they sound like garden variety Trumpists? Exact same sick, anti-social mentality. And, yes, of course, the smart ones all flee the cult, leaving mostly morons without a capacity for critical thinking-- again, just like Trumpists. You've probably seen this definition of "idiot" before. (The bride in this photo fled the community and became a real person in Berlin.)




©2000 by Howie Klein. Leading The Progressive Fight Online Since 2000

downwithtyranny@gmail.com

Blue America - Building A Progressive Future - Donate Here: